Conflict Reader

Photo Source: Dawn

One could understand the rightwing parties and their student wings in Universities objecting to the celebration of Valentine Day for political reasons. But why would the learned courts and the highest institution of the country – President of Pakistan object to the Valentine Day?

Conflict Reader # 15, 17 February 2017

Pakistan
Court, Society and Valentine Day: Is expression of love against our culture?

CR Comment

D. Suba Chandran
Professor
International Strategic and Security Studies Programme (ISSSP)
National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bangalore

On 13 February 2017, the Islamabad High Court directed the Federal Ministry of Information and the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA) to prohibit the “celebration of Valentine\'s Day in public spaces and government offices across the country with immediate effect.” (Dawn, 14 February 2017).

The court order was the result of an individual petition, who had earlier complained that the celebration of Valentine\'s Day is “against Islamic teachings” and “should be banned immediately” as the celebrations promote “immorality, nudity and indecency”. 

During the recent years, Valentine’s Day has been under attack by a section, primarily led by the Rightists – political parties at the larger level and their student wings in Universities. Especially in the educational institutions, from Peshawar to Karachi, there were protests and brawls between those who celebrate love and those who oppose. Anti-Valentine day campaigns – the Haya day, has been increasing during the recent Februaries. 

Last year, a person holding one of the highest institutions - Mamnoon Hussain, the President of Pakistan went on record asking the people not to celebrate the Valentine Day, as he considered it was against a Muslim tradition and has “no connection with our culture” and hence “should be avoided.” This year, the Islamabad High Court went a step ahead and prohibited the celebration in public spaces.

One could understand the rightwing parties and their student wings in Universities objecting to the celebration of Valentine Day for political reasons. But why would the learned courts and the highest institution of the country – President of Pakistan object to the Valentine Day?

A primary problem is the failure of the secular and moderate response to counter this vicious narrative that the Valentine Day was against the tradition and culture. Not only Pakistan, but the entire South Asian region – may not have historically celebrated “Valentine Day”, but there are enough references in our cultural ethos and religious epics underlining the celebration of love. 

Despite the interferences and impositions from radical strains, the society remains predominantly Sufi in South Asia. In fact, one could extend this geographic fold from Central Asia into Southeast Asia across the mainland and the oceans. A society that took pride with its Sufi teaching and found solace in numerous Sufi Pirs and Babas, by no imagination, can condemn celebrating love as not a part of their culture. From Rehmat Baba across the Durand Line to Baba Ghulam Shah across the Indo-Pak Line of Control (LoC), the symbols and preachings of the Sufi saints revolved around peace, love and harmony. 

The biggest symbol of love, not only in South Asia but all over the world – the Taj Mahal is not a western creation. And by no stretch of imagination, one could argue that it did not reflect the Muslim tradition in South Asia. 

Separated only by few kilometres from Agra, where the majestic symbol of love – the Taj Mahal is yet another legend - the Radha Krishna in Vrindavan near Mathura. The Ras Leela legend believes that even today the couple dance in the evenings every day! 

Neither the Taj Mahal nor Radha Krishna were created or brought into the region. They represent our history and our culture. In fact, rest of the world celebrate these two as a symbol of love from Toronto to Berlin to Brisbane. The globalization of Radha Krishna movements and its public expression in the streets of America, Europe and Australia led by non-South Asians will highlight what this region has exported to rest of the world. 

So when did love or public celebration of it became “not a part of our culture”? True Valentine Day may have been from the West, but as explained above, South Asia has been celebrating the essence of 14 February in its own ways.

In Pakistan, the problem starts from the Universities. This is a part of an ongoing struggle between the liberal and rightwing students to capture the public space within the educational institutions. Besides, a section among the students would even complain that those who oppose such celebrations are essentially those “frustrated” who could never manage a single date!

The larger problem takes place in the streets, with religious parties and rightwing organizations seeing 14 February as an opportunity to assert their position. For them, it is more of a political space; to protect the culture and tradition, there is so much these parties could do; but they would rather pick up the Valentine day, for it is a easy target.

What is surprising is the intervention by the judiciary in this context. Why would a learned judge, who is well aware of the globalization process would come down on the subject? Is South Asia entering a phase – where even the mainstream judiciary is getting influenced by the Right? If this is a beginning, then it would be even more dangerous than few rightwing protesters going after couples in the public. 

Such legal pronouncements by the learned courts may further strengthen the Rightwing groups and encourage enlarging their narrow agenda. 

The West, in fact is proud and even own the symbols of love from South Asia. It is a pity, that we don’t.

Other Publications

Left-wing Extremism in India
March 2020 | Brief

Another Maoist ambush in Chhattisgarh: Lessons from a Failure

read more
After Doha
March 2020 | Analysis

The US-Taliban deal will lead to an Afghan Civil War

read more
The US-Taliban deal in Doha
March 2020 | Analysis

Five reasons why Pakistan is ecstatic

read more
Pakistan
November 2019 | Analysis

The Fazlur Fizzle: The Azadi March will fail, for four reasons

read more
Afghan Elections
October 2019 | Analysis

The Afghans are in for a long haul; so should the rest of us

read more
India & Pakistan
April 2019 | Brief

Crossing the Pak Rubicon: Six premises that India questioned at Balakot

read more
Afghanistan
March 2019 | Comment

Dialogue with the Taliban: Six Questions

read more
The Road to Doha
February 2019 | Comment

Why the Taliban continues with Violence despite Peace Talks: Three Explanations

read more
Afghanistan
January 2019 | Comment

All in the name of Peace

read more
Early Warning Conflict Alert
January 2019 | Brief

South Asia: Five Conflicts to Watch in 2019

read more
Sri Lanka
November 2018 | Brief

Reconvene the Parliament and Respect the Constitution

read more
Myanmar
October 2018 | Analysis

The UN, Myanmar and the Rohingyas

read more
Kashmir
September 2018 | Analysis

Building Peace Momentum in J&K

read more
Af-Pak
May 2018 | Brief

Will Pakistan walk the Afghan Talk?

read more
Balochistan
May 2018 | Analysis

Who is targeting the Hazara? And Why?

read more
Radicalism Project
April 2018 | Analysis

“I am not Malala”: Deciphering the anti-Malala Sentiment in Pakistan

read more
Afghanistan I Sectarain
April 2018 | Analysis

The Sectarian Spiral in Afghanistan: Who? And Why?

read more
Sri Lanka
March 2018 | Analysis

The Anti-Muslim Violence in Sri Lanka

read more
Maldives
March 2018 | Analysis

The Political Crisis in Maldives

read more
Gender Violence
January 2018 | Analysis

South Asia's Kasur Problem: Hypocritical Civil Society, Insensitive Investigation, Indifferent Judiciary and a Hard State

read more
Regional
January 2018 | Analysis

South Asia's Conflict Peripheries

read more
Bilateral I Indo-Pak
January 2018 | Analysis

Will the Indo-Pak Relations improve in 2018?

read more
Myanmar
December 2017 | Analysis

South Asia's Rohingya Predicament

read more
Radicalism Project
November 2017 | Brief

The State surrenders to the Mullahs: Why did the Military aid? And why did the Government agree?

read more
Balochistan
November 2017 | Analysis

The Slow Burn: One Province and Five Actors

read more
Radicalism Project
November 2017 | Analysis

The Ghost of Mumtaz Qadri

read more
Peace Alert
November 2017 | Analysis

Towards an Inclusive Kashmir Dialogue

read more
Af-Pak
October 2017 | Analysis

Joshua and Caitlan: Story of Victims, Rescuers and Perpetrators

read more
Radicalism Project
October 2017 | Analysis

The Islamic State in South Asia: Why are the State and Society reluctant to acknowledge?

read more
Myanmar
September 2017 | Analysis

The Rohingya Politics: Between Strong Military, Weak Government, Rakhine Faultlines and Ma Ba Tha

read more
Myanmar
September 2017 | Analysis

The Rohingya Conflict: The Burning Villages, Social Media and the Internationalization of Violence

read more
Pakistan
August 2017 | Analysis

Jirga and Gender Violence

read more
Society
July 2017 | Analysis

Pashtunwali, Kashmiriyat and Sufi: Are our Social Codes under Stress?

read more
Sectarian
July 2017 | Analysis

Pakistan's Parachinar Problem

read more
Afghanistan
June 2017 | Analysis

Afghans’ Kabul Problem

read more
Pakistan
May 2017 | Comment

Fighting Taliban and the Islamic State: Don't prioritize

read more
India-Pakistan
April 2017 | Comment

Cross-LoC Interactions: Low Hanging Kashmir Fruit

read more
ISIS
April 2017 | Comment

Fighting the Daesh: A Regional Counter IS Strategy

read more
Pakistan
March 2017 | Brief

The Raddul Fasaad Fallouts: Will it succeed where Zarb-e-Azb failed?

read more
Pakistan
March 2017 | Comment

Deep-rooted Misogyny: Offend her; she will forgive in the name of tradition

read more
Pakistan
February 2017 | Brief

Hafiz Saeed Detention: Tactical Choice or Strategic Decision?

read more
Pakistan
January 2017 | Analysis

Terror revisits Parachinar: Kurram Agency’s Ten Year Sectarian Itch

read more
Pakistan
January 2017 | Analysis

State vs Militant Groups: What if the Genie has a mind of its own?

read more
Pakistan
January 2017 | Analysis

Sectarian Violence: No More Deja Vu

read more
Af-Pak
January 2017 | Comment

Pakistan’s Afghan Policy: What Shapes? Who Shapes? And through What Strategies?

read more
Pakistan
January 2017 | Analysis

Saudi Arabia, Iran and the ISIS: Pakistan’s Middle East Conundrum

read more
Pakistan
December 2016 | Analysis

Honour Killing: No Honour, Only Crime and Evil

read more
Pakistan
December 2016 | Analysis

Foreign Fighters: Why Pashtuns and Punjabis?

read more
Af-Pak
December 2016 | Analysis

Across the Durand Line: Who is in Control?

read more
Af-Pak
December 2016 | Analysis

Zarb-e-Azb: Pakistan, Afghanistan and the TTP

read more
Pakistan
December 2016 | Comment

And Now, They Are Coming For Our Children

read more
Af-Pak
December 2016 | Analysis

A Tale of Two Taliban: Linkages between Afghan and Pakistan Taliban

read more
Af-Pak
December 2016 | Analysis

Torkham Clashes: Pakistan, Afghanistan and the Durand Line

read more